Log in to your IBTimes Account

close
ID
Password

Palm Pre versus iPhone: Who's the real winner? (1)



By Charles Smith
22 October 2009 @ 02:40 am BST

London - Palm Pre, the latest smartphone from Palm Inc., is selling very well in the UK where it was launched last week and threatens to upstage Apple Inc.'s iconic iPhone as the most-wanted handset in the soon-to-come holiday season. But who's the real winner?


Palm Pre
he new Palm Pre cellular phone can be seen in New York June 3, 2009. The Pre smartphone from Palm Inc received mostly positive reviews and predictions it will be a tough competitor to Apple Inc's iPhone. (Reuters Photo)
1 of 1

According to an O2 spokesperson, people are buying more Palm Pre than all other devices (including the iPhone 3GS) combined, though some analysts claim that the latest iPhone is selling at least five times more than Pre.

The intense competition between iPhone and Palm Pre has also piqued the media's interest, which wasted no time in dubbing Palm Pre's launch as "finally a REAL iPhone killer has arrived."

But, what is it that makes Palm Pre so hot, so "much-wanted" and so "iPhone killer"?

First, let us do away with the similarities.

Both the phones are nearly similar in shape and size and weight, comes with quad-band, EDGE/GSM, 3G/HSDPA support at up to 3.6Mbit/s, Bluetooth, 802.11b/g Wi-Fi for internet access, and a 3.5mm headphone jack.

Both have Bluetooth support for wireless headsets and boast of a similar sized multitouch screen display (iPhone's is a wee bit bigger) with 320 x 480 resolution that allows you to pinch, flick and swirl your fingers across the touchpad for intuitive navigation. It also allows users to scroll, zoom in and out and flip through web pages, photos, spreadsheets and more.

Both have GPS capability for location-based services, such as the built-in Google Maps, and an accelerometer that senses if you rotate the device and changes the display to match.

Like iPhone, Palm Pre tops in form factor and has minimal keys on the outside as it focuses more on touchscreen experience. On the left side, it has volume up/down buttons, and a mute switch on the top, next to the on/off button while on the right side, it has a small flap covering the microUSB connector, and a single centre button is located beneath the screen.

And, both are priced in the UK nearly the same. Though Palm Pre isn't currently available on PAYG yet, but it is available at O2 stores (Palm Pre is also available at Carphone Warehouse, Phones4U, and other O2 partners) in the UK on five differing contracts which see the 18 month plans coming in at £44.05 (1200 mins talktime, 500 texts, unlimited net access) and £73.41 (3000 mins talktime, 500 texts, unlimited net access), as well as the 24 month £34.26 plan (600 mins talktime, 500 texts, unlimited net access) giving you the Palm Pre for "free" while the 18 month £29.38 and £34.26 plans (75/125 and 600/500 talktime/texts respectively) will see you coughing up some £97 extra in order to secure the smartphone. Definitely not the best of tariff deals, but, unfortunately, there is nothing we can do about that.

This article is copyrighted by IBTimes.

    Click!
  • Rate this article:

Comments
1.
22 Oct 2009, 06:10 BST

the phones are not similar in size at all
2.
22 Oct 2009, 13:28 BST

The iPhone can import GMail contacts and events, but not Facebook.
3.
22 Oct 2009, 16:54 BST

The Palm Pre can be plugged into a machine and run as a USB removable drive; iPhone can't. Palm Pre has a removable battery which allows you to install higher capacity models for longer talk time (also compatible with Palm Centro batteries); iPhone's battery is not removable.
4.
23 Oct 2009, 07:35 BST

While the pre has all these other nea features, it's no good for businesses who rely on large amounts of email everyday - it's far too slow. Waiting fo the inbox to load or calendars to appear is painful compared to the iPhone and blackberry. All the processing power seems to be used on a fancy interface. Composing new messages or even opening one that just arrived takes 10-20 seconds - and this is over wifi! The blackberry and iPhone have it over speed - yeh the facebook and gmail synergy is clever - but who emails from their gmail account to their facebook friends for business?
5.
23 Oct 2009, 15:27 BST

I listen to books. I Phone doesn't support fast forward or reverse. How does the Pre handle this? Can you easily move backwards and/or forwards to repeat or skip a few seconds of the recording?
6.
24 Oct 2009, 12:31 BST

"Palm Pre features a slide-down Qwerty keypad that makes texting more easy and convenient" - for stubborn technophobes and morbidly obese. I wish they would just stick to full touch screen functionality, I for one won't buy a phone with a slide of any kind let alone qwerty on a touch screen! I hope they fade out as the older people who can't be bothered to utilise the touch screen fade out.

Post Your Comment

*Name


advertisement
advertisement
 
 
IBTimes © 2010 IBTimes Company. All Rights Reserved. Partners